Brooks Beast Vs New Balance 1540 is a hard comparison.

Both Brooks Beast and New Balance 1540 are motion control shoes and will help runners with severe overpronation.

However, these two shoes are not at all similar as you will find out in the following sections.

Due to some minor things that I personally like, I’ve picked one shoe over the other. However, that doesn’t mean that the other shoe is bad. It is just a personal preference.

Also, I have provided you with all the required information in the below sections so that you are able to pick the right pair for yourself…

So, without further ado, let’s jump into the detailed comparison of Brooks Beast vs New Balance 1540.

Brooks Beast Vs New Balance 1540-min

This is our winner

Last update on 2024-04-15 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

New Balance 1540

Why did we choose this?

  • Forgiving cushioning.
  • Soft protection.
  • Mordern look.
  • Better style.
  • Has more number of widths.
  • Excellent ankle stability

Brooks Beast Vs. New Balance 1540 – A head to head comparison

We have covered all the broad differences between Brooks Beast and New Balance 1540.

These are subtler differences and you will get to know a lot more information about Brooks Beast 20 vs New Balance 1540v3.

Let’s read on…

Brooks Beast Vs New Balance 1540 – An Overview

Both Books Beast and New Balance 1540 are motion control running shoes and provide you with an ample amount of cushioning and stability.

Brooks Beast in this version has become more in line with the other stability shoes from Brooks whereas New Balance 1540 is still using similar technology as it was doing in the previous versions.

However, both of these shoes will provide you with great comfort and will provide you with maximum support during your long runs.

We have covered all these and a lot more in the following sections so that you can focus on the important details during your own research.

So, without further ado, let’s begin…

Brooks Beast Vs New Balance 1540 – Features at a glance

Brooks Beast 20 New Balance 1540v3
Brooks Beast '20 Black/Ebony/Grey 11 New Balance Women's 1540 V3 Running Shoe, Natural Indigo/Natural Indigo, 5
Check Price!
Check Price!
Price $119.95 $169.99
Type Motion Control Motion Control
Heel-to-toe Drop 12mm 10mm
Weight 10.7oz / 303.3g (Women)
11.7oz / 331.7g (Men)
11.2 oz/318 g (Women)
14.9 oz/423 g (Men)
Arch Support Flat To Medium Flat To Medium
Technology GuideRails, BioMoGo DNA ENCAP, Rollbar
Sizes 6.0 – 13.0 (Women)
8.0 – 16.0 (Men)
5.0 – 13.0 (Women)
7.0 – 16.0 (Men)
Width Normal, Wide D, Extra Wide 2E (Women)
Normal, Wide 2E, Extra Wide 2E (Men)
Narrow, Standard, X-wide, Wide, XX-Wide (Women)
Narrow, Standard, X-wide, Wide, XX-Wide (Men)
Use Long Distance, Speed / Track, Cross Training, Treadmill, Road Long Distance, Road Running, Cross Training, Treadmill
Editor’s Rating 4 star rating-92X25-min 4 and a half star-92X25-min
Check Price!
Check Price!

The main differences between Brooks Beast Vs New Balance 1540

  • Brooks Beast is a motion control running shoe that uses GuideRails. On the other hand, New Balance 1540, also a motion control running shoe uses roller bar.
  • Brooks Beast is lighter than New Balance 1540 due to the way it has used different materials.
  • The latest generation of Brooks Beast is 20 wheres the current version of New Balance 1540 is 3.
  • New Balance 1540 comes in a lot of widths and will fit almost all feet widths whereas Brooks Beast comes in only three widths.
  • New Balance 1540 has more number of sizes available for both genders than Brooks Beast.
  • New Balance 1540 has ENCAP midsole whereas Brooks Beast has BioMoGo midsole.
  • Brooks Beast has a heel-to-toe drop of 12mm whereas New Balance 1540 has a drop of 10 mm.


The outsole of both of these shoes are well covered with blown rubber and will provide you with excellent grip and stability while running. However, if you observe closely, you will find some differences in the outsole of both of these running shoes. In New Balance 1540, the outsole is a single layer of rubber. It has deep groves and are not separated into pieces. On the other hand, Brooks Beast has separate rubber pieces and the company may have tried to do this for a better heel to toe transition. Also, in Brooks Beast, in the central part of the outer surface, there is no additional rubber layer. In other words, the blown rubber is present only in the high impact zones on the outer sole of Brooks Beast. If Brooks uses segmentation for better heel to toe transition, New Balance uses different rubber in that zone for transition. It is very apparent as they have marked that region with a different color. Overall, both of these shoes though handles the flexibility and grip in different ways, they actually will provide you with excellent ride quality. Related: Brooks Beast Vs Asics Kayano: Which One Should You Choose?


The midsole of these two running shoes is very different. They use different technologies to handle motion control. Brooks Beast uses GuideRails which is a separate piece of material inserted between the midsole and the upper. They bring back your knees to the line of motion, thus minimizing the impact of pronation on your lower body. On the other hand, New Balance 1540 uses a roller bar to essentially achieve almost the same effect. It is interesting to note that, Brooks Beast, before version 20 used to use something called progressive diagonal roller bar or PDRB for motion control. They changed it to GuideRails to make this more technologically at par with other pronation shoes like Adrenaline. Also, there is a huge difference in the materials used in the midsole. Brooks Beast uses BioMoGo DNA and New Balance 1540 uses ENCAP. Does that change the cushioning experience? Well, a bit. Some runners find BioMoGo DNA to be more comfortable whereas some find ENCAP to be more cushiony. It all boils down to personal choice. There are a couple of more differences like the heel to toe drop. Brooks Beast has a heel drop of 12 mm which is almost a standard for this range, whereas New Balance 1540 has a heel drop of 10 mm. However, these two running shoes are rugged and will last you for 300 to 500 miles or up to 3 to 6 months.  


The upper of these two running shoes are completely different. Brooks Beast is a complete mesh with some occasional overlays, New balance 1540 is a combination of mesh and leather and provides you with a completely different feel. 

Loo-wise brooks Beast is more modern whereas New Balance has the look of 80’s sneakers which is the hallmark of New Balance.

However, both of these running shoes are very spacious and will not crush your feet. They are available in different toe-box widths. Brooks Beast has Normal, Wide D, Wide 2E for women whereas it has Normal, Wide 2E, Extra Wide 4E for men.

The number of toe-box widths that are present in New Balance 1540 is more than Brooks Beast. It has Narrow, Standard, X-wide, Wide, XX-Wide for women and the same set of widths for men as well.

In that way, New Balance 1540 caters to a wider range of runners as it has more sizes also.

Both of the shoes have excellent padding in the collar and the tongue and will keep your ankle very stable.


Brooks Beast is a bit lighter than New balance 1540. My understanding is, there is a lot going on on the upper of New Balance 1540.

With 1540 you will find leather like material and mesh on the upper. These leather like materials are heavier than mesh. Brooks Beast on the other hand has only mesh on the upper. Consequently, it is lighter than New Balance 1540.

Weight of Brooks Beast is 11.7oz / 331.7g for men and 10.7oz / 303.3g for women whereas the weight of New Balance 1540 is 14.9 oz /423 grams for men and 11.2 oz /318 grams for women.


Price wise Brooks Beast is a bit cheaper than New Balance 1540. You will have to spend around $10-$15 less for Brooks Beast

That’s all with the differences and similarities between Brooks Beast 20 and New Balnce 1540v3.

If you want to look at some alternatives to both the shoes, then read on…

Similar Shoes

Running Shoes Similar To Brooks Beast 20

There are a couple of running shoes that can serve as a good alternative to Brooks Beast 20.

Here is the list of alternatives of Brooks Beast that you may like. 

Running Shoes Similar to New Balance 1540v3

There are some running shoes that can serve as a good alternative to New Balance 1540. However, we are still working on the list

In the meantime, here is the best alternative to New Balance 1540.

Asics GT-2000 9 Running Shoes
  • No-sew mesh upper:
  • Rearfoot and Forefoot GEL Technology Cushioning System: Attenuates shock during impact and toe-off phases, and allows movement in multiple planes as the foot transitions through the gait cycle.
  • FLYTEFOAM Midsole Technology: Our FLYTEFOAM technology provides exceptional bounce back and responsiveness no matter the distance, utilizing organic super fibers to help reduce packing out that traditionally happens with softer, low density foams.

Last update on 2024-04-14 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API


We have tried to provide all the required details for “Brooks Beast Vs New Balance 1540 review”.

You will get all the required information to make the correct decision for yourself.

However, due to more sizes and toe box availability we picked New Balance 1540 as the winner.

Let us know if you have any further questions.

Brooks Beast Vs New Balance 1540 Pinterest-min
Madhusree Basu

Madhusree Basu

Author, Admin

Blogger and a fitness enthusiast. She loves running and Yoga and everything in between. She started running to manage her weight and to eat to her heart’s content. A true foodie at heart she shares whatever knowledge she has gained throughout the years about weight management and fitness.

Latest Comparisons